An apposite quotation

Half of the harm that is done in this world is due to people who want to feel important. They don’t mean to do harm but the harm does not interest them. -T.S. Eliot, poet (1888-1965)

I found this nice little quotation today. It encapsulates my own opinion on these matters so pithily, concisely and, well, poetically! It could apply to so many of the topics of my blog posts: politics, global warming, the Stolen Generation, misplaced paternalism towards indigenous people, the Iraq War, what makes George Bush tick…

In fact, this nice little quotation even applies to the draconian water restrictions in Victoria at the moment. They are being imposed merely so that the government can feel important and appear to be doing something, but the truth of the matter is that the majority of water use and wastage is in agriculture and industry, so cutting domestic use is essentially pointless and inconveniences everyone hugely. That’s one thing for which I would criticise many greenies of my acquaintance – they say “this is the perfect solution” (eg, wind farms) without looking at the practicalities or the broader picture, and recognising that there are always drawbacks to everything (eg, wind farms are unsightly, create noise pollution and may endanger rare parrots).

No solution to anything is ever going to be perfect. It’s a question of weighing up the bad and the good consequences. Sometimes, despite good intentions, a solution can cause more harm than good.

Going to another current topic, I’m sure the US Republicans thought: “Liberate Iraq from Saddam Hussein and force Iraq to become a liberal democracy, that will make things much better.” Um, maybe not.

The situation in Iraq reminds me of Yugoslavia after Tito died. Removing a dictator always seems like a good thing, but when the dictator had been holding vicious sectarian disputes in check by his oppressive regime, the results can be disasterous. By removing the dictator, the lid was taken off the sectarian disputes and all hell broke loose…

As per my previous post, I continue to hope that Saddam is not executed, despite his crimes. I suspect that it is being done for precisely the same reason as the water restrictions; so that people can look like they are doing something important and productive in an otherwise hopeless situation.


Well, latest news is that Saddam was executed anyway. We’ll see whether this is a solution or, as I suspect, a creation of a worse problem.



Filed under Iraq, middle east, politics, Saddam Hussein, water restrictions

2 responses to “An apposite quotation

  1. iain

    I say a thing about your water restrictions on the TV showing repeat water waster’s having their house hold supplies cut to a trickle. We are in a rural circumstance and have lived on water tanks for the last twenty years. So at time like this we carry on as usual in fact we are doing very well this year having had to buy water only once(at a cot of $100 for a load of about 3000 gallons) we understand the value of water in a way that my in the city never will. However I do appreciate what you are saying about agriculture and industry. One of the measures that the government is taking up here in Queensland is to reuse effluent industry and agriculture.
    Take heart though the prognosticators are predicting a return to more normal rainfall next year so you shall be able to have those luxurious baths, water the garden and wash the car once again

  2. Legal Eagle

    I agree that water is a precious resource and should not be wasted. However, I don’t think water restrictions are the best way to go about it.

    Apparently, in Victoria, 9% of our water is used in the household. But another 9% of Victoria’s water is wasted because the infrastructure and pipes are old – it just leaks into the ground. Why doesn’t the government fix this instead? And we could try to develop desalination technologies and the like. No, it’s easier to just punish the people…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s